Ever since I was in 9th grade I have known that my purpose in life is to help others realize how amazing they are. Sometimes my means for achieving this have perhaps appeared clumsy and weird, especially since while I have studied these subjects on my own, without getting a related degree (my B.A. and M.A. have nothing to do with this), I am not a therapist, dietician, or physician. I remember in 9th grade reading a book about physical and emotional development as girls travel through puberty, and sharing my newly acquired knowledge with a girlfriend, and soon her friends (girls and boys) were coming to me for advice so I then read the boy version. Since then, I have keenly studied everything I can get my hands on related to psychology, neuroscience, nutrition, exercise, spirituality, personal growth, and so on. But usually, while these lessons and instruction have informed me in a way that they have shaped the way I intellectually tune in to people, I have found that my most productive and rewarding guide has been my own intuition. And sometimes my intuition has led me to accompany someone on their personal journey in ways that would never be in a textbook.
That being said, while I am certain that business and marketing books and classes and webinars encourage companies and distributors to prey on consumers’ deepest emotional vulnerability, I am quite certain that health providers, both physicians and psychological, would agree that this approach is extremely damaging. I am talking about the way companies and individuals make the most of pervasive, free social networking media in order to get us where we are most vulnerable – our insecurities about our appearance. Whether you are on Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram, Twitter, etc – it is virtually impossible to escape all of the Before and After “success” stories. I completely understand the seductiveness, first of feasting our eyes on the transformation, and then reading the unbelievable speed and superhuman degree of commitment with which this transformation was achieved. Ever since I started reading Shape Magazine in my 20s (I don’t anymore), I also have been fascinated by these inspiring stories. Shape Magazine, to its credit, only publishes stories where the protagonist has lost weight by making lifestyle changes (i.e. not by starving and consuming only blended liquids), and has kept it off for a few years. These types of stories are truly motivating. They provide hope. When I look at the B&A pictures on Facebook (I have unfollowed every single person I know who posts these, but a few creep through), I quite frankly feel dismay. It makes me feel sad that adults would see their value summed up in a Before picture where they apparently hated themselves and then an After picture where suddenly they have achieved Nirvana, have all the answers, and are eager to teach (read: sell to) others. Some people do continue to live with some positive, healthy changes that undoubtedly are a great improvement on the tailspin in which they were previously living. That thought makes me happy. And I also am happy for the people who are achieving their financial goals, because making money is important. I am happy for the people who finally feel that they are part of a group that is encouraging personal development, supporting others, believing in self, because I know that sort of social group can be hard to find. Those are great things. Where I am most sad isn’t with what I see as unethical practices such as exaggeration and misrepresentation. I am most dismayed by the reduction of wonderful, kind, smart, beautiful people, to a set of images that focuses on something as superficial and impermanent as one’s body, primarily one’s midsection. This is not mindful living, mindful work, or mindful transformation. Mindfulness, I think, is about living in a way that is paying attention, being authentic, being compassionate, being present. Often in my Poga classes I invite participants to let go of the tendency to compare. When we come to the mat, let us let go of the notions that we have of who we were (and looked like) 5 years ago, 5 minutes ago, or our vision of ourselves in 5 months. Let us focus on how and who we are today, in this very moment, this very breath. There is no Before and After because Before no longer exists, and After is never promised, so all we have is Now. Who we are right Now is what matters the most, and when we start to notice our breath, the way our body feels, our emotions, our thoughts, the way we react or don’t react – that is the beginning of true transformation. This type of awareness is not available in a cleanse, and there are no guarantees or shiny promises. Learning to cultivate this type of awareness is not something that will be evident in photos of people in different stages of undress, in different lighting conditions. But this is the type of journey that I would love for more people, especially parents, to be curious about. I don’t want my 14-year-old daughter to see her body as a sum of different parts, which reflect values and their lack of, such as commitment, discipline, morality. It is my wish for her to love, or at least be kind to, the way she looks and feels. To me, there is no dignity in posting these sorts of photos and updates on social media. There is no compassion for self or others in so doing. There is no kindness in denying ourselves real food. I want my daughter to accept that certain stages of life have different effects on our priorities, energy, motivation – and it is all part of the journey and it’s all good. Do we have to stay there? No. But let’s not hate it or make fun of it or invite others to do the same. And while my parenting is always a work in progress, one thing I am absolutely certain about is that our children are our mirrors, and they will absorb and model everything we do. So let’s try to proceed mindfully, starting with how we treat and talk to and think of ourselves. Not Before. Or After. Now.
11 Comments
2/17/2015 04:33:49 am
I wholeheartedly agree with you. Too much emphasis is put on what we look like on the outside, rather than what we feel like on the inside when it comes to healthy living. If we paid more attention (ie if we were more mindful) of what our bodies were telling us, we may be able to correct the cause of the excess weight, rather than dealing with the effect via fad diets. Because when those fads fail us, we tend to blame ourselves, thus beginning the cycle over again. Kindness, compassion, and care all lead to self-love, which in turn, will help us care for the bodies we have now, rather than what the media and diet companies want us to believe we can achieve with their products.
Reply
Don
2/17/2015 04:41:40 am
Well said Mrs. Rosen.
Reply
Susanne
2/18/2015 01:46:03 am
YES! I see excess weight as a clue our body is giving us that somethin' ain't right. Just like, if we get frequent headaches. We don't hate our head if it aches, but we hate our belly if it's jiggly. We need to treat our body with reverence and listen to its clues. And ignore all those messages in the media, even if they come from friends. Our body knows better.
Reply
Don
2/17/2015 04:40:42 am
Thank you for this. I've been guilty of a before/after photo, but I think we're still FB buds because -- thanks in large part to you -- I lost weight slowly... through smarter eating and exercise. No crazy stuff (except for a Ragnar here and there). No more before/after photos from me either. More harm than good coming from a little bragging. You rock!
Reply
Susanne
2/18/2015 01:48:22 am
Don, you are a huge source of inspiration to me. I think of you every time I opt for the stairs over the escalator or elevator :) And actually - I'm not against all B&A pictures, such as yours - the few you have posted are what I consider REAL transformation, and the intent behind it is 100% to inspire others and be a role model. I think intent is very important, and it's a big part of being mindful. Keep doing what you're doing.
Reply
Nikki
2/17/2015 07:49:10 am
I'm so glad somebody finally put in words what I have been thinking for months. Everytime I would see a before/after pic & how wonderful they feel now I would start to question my own self image. I think it's wrong to market yourself or diet supplements you are selling in that manner.
Reply
Susanne
2/18/2015 01:51:42 am
Nikki, thanks for commenting. It's funny (in a sad way) how we women can be so self-critical and immediately internalize all those messages around us. No wonder the diet industry is still thriving, no matter what the rest of the economy is doing! Anyway you are and look fantastic, and these feelings we get when we see or hear the shaming messages are an opportunity for us to notice how we feel and learn a little more about ourselves.
Reply
If only everyone self-educated themselves on the "quick" fix solutions, before and after gimmicks, and blatent misinformation void of scientific proof as you do, Susanne perhaps we would be seeing all of this insanity on FB. I have huge issues with the diet inductry praying on our insecurities and vulnerability. Its a multi million dollar industry and in the end leaves su with sluggish metabolisms and unbalenced hormone levels whcih lead to weight gain and depression (among other things). In addition most of these products are not third party tested so we dont even know whats in them! On top of that they dont teach us how to eat real food. They basically teach you to eat and then be anorexic for 3-5 days until you can eat again. What message is that sending to our young girls who are watching us?? I assume this madness will all continue unless more people speak up like you did!!! Like you said...this before/after quick fix seduction has been around for a very very long time....and I agree it is portrayed in a way thats hard to say no...unless you know better. And a lot of people dont know better (which I'm quite frankly suprized at in an educated commmunity like ours) But I actually believe that the majority of people ARE smarter than that--we happen just to hear more frequently from the ones who fell into the trap because they shout so loudly and often about it on FB. Truth be told people ask me on a daily basis to sort this all out and I honestly believe that more people do the right thing are not seduced by the unethical choice and take the healthy long-term success route in terms of health and wellness. I always say to myself "if this product/system/shake/supplement really worked then every single one of us would have a six pack, the perect body composition, a healthy choleterol panel and be truly happy and at peace with our bodies". And it would be on store shelves and not be sold by our local friends as a private "inbox" special deal." And as we all knwo this is not the case. As unsexy as it is...the only solution is hard work. Hard work and a committment to yourself over a long period of time -thats the answer and its proven to work. Glad you blogged about this
Reply
Susanne
2/18/2015 02:05:34 am
Thanks, Jenn, for reading and commenting. I can certainly understand both sides of the phenomenon, as I have been at some point intrigued by all the "success" hoopla and I recognize that it is easy to justify anything in the name of "helping others." I mean, who doesn't want a quick way to undo stupid choices? Who doesn't want to earn enough money that you can quit your energy-sucking job and spend more time with your kids? And I also understand the appeal of having easy, pre-packaged shakes - we're all so busy and burnt out, anything easy is appealing. I put a protein powder in my green smoothie more often than not, because there are only so many hard-boiled eggs I can stomach (but I do make sure it's top quality and few ingredients, all pronounceable ;) ) I think all of this is just another example of the mindlessness with which most of us are functioning, as we aren't really thinking through the consequences of our posts. Who knows how long this will last, but in the meantime, I think it's best to really be mindful of whom we follow on Facebook etc, and at the same time become more aware of our attitudes toward our own body.
Reply
Amy
2/17/2015 11:23:01 am
Thanks for a comprehensive summation of what I have been feeling and thinking. I tried the cleanse as a detox not to lose weight but was immediately reminded of my past eating issues and stopped after a few days. I was told however that if I didn't fast it wouldn't work and that everyone on this team had to follow the designed program to the letter. I felt ashamed that I couldn't do it. Very self destructive thoughts ensued and thanks to a good friend remembered what's really important. Makes me very sad as well.
Reply
Susanne
2/18/2015 02:09:57 am
Hi Amy, thanks for sharing - I am certain that your experience was not an isolated one and it's exactly why I posted this blog entry. I was hoping that people who experienced what you have, would realize that they are not at fault. I appreciate your openly sharing a side that I think may be hidden from most, because let's face it, who wants to "admit failure" especially when it appears that so many others are thriving with the system? Amy, I'm glad you have such a good friend who redirected you - and that you opened up to her in the first place. Now you are even wiser and I am sure kinder to your body and your self. Hugs.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
Susanne NavasWellness coach, athlete, mom, entrepreneur. I love helping people mindfully reboot their health & joy. Archives
February 2023
Categories |